FAIR Plan plus DIC vs surplus lines: which is better?
Two contracts or one. The right answer depends on your home, not on which sounds better.
The comparison, head to head
The honest summary is that neither structure wins on every axis. Surplus lines tends to win on simplicity and breadth; FAIR Plan plus DIC wins on availability and on the guarantee-fund question.
| FAIR Plan + DIC | Surplus lines | |
|---|---|---|
| Number of policies | Two, from two carriers | One |
| Number of deductibles | Two, and they may differ | One |
| Claims process | Depends which policy responds | One carrier, one claim |
| Risk of a gap between policies | Real - the limits must be coordinated | None, it is one contract |
| Breadth of coverage | Approximates a standard HO-3 | Often broader than FAIR Plan plus DIC |
| CIGA protection if the insurer fails | FAIR Plan yes; DIC depends on the carrier | No - not CIGA-backed |
| Availability | Broad, for homes that qualify | The carrier still has to want the risk |
| Wildfire deductible | Standard dollar deductible typically | May be a percentage of dwelling value |
The CIGA trade-off, stated plainly
This is the one difference people are most often not told about. Surplus lines carriers are non-admitted - state-approved to write risks the admitted market will not, but not licensed by California. Coverage placed with them is not protected by the California Insurance Guarantee Association, so if the insurer becomes insolvent there is no state fund standing behind your unpaid claim. CDI maintains a List of Approved Surplus Line Insurers (LASLI) of non-admitted carriers it has pre-reviewed for capitalization and asset quality.
That is a real trade-off, not a disqualifier - surplus lines is a large, established, well-capitalised market and it is how most hard-to-place property in the United States gets written. But you should be told about it before you sign, and we tell you. See admitted vs surplus lines for the full explanation.
Where the two-policy structure actually goes wrong
The failure mode specific to FAIR Plan plus DIC is not price, it is coordination. Two policies from two carriers can leave a loss falling into the space between them.
- Mismatched limits - if the DIC's dwelling limit is set below the FAIR Plan's, a large loss is underinsured on one side
- Two deductibles on one event - a loss that triggers both policies can cost you both deductibles
- Timing - the two policies can renew on different dates, so a lapse on one leaves the other doing half a job
- Disputed responsibility - when it is not obvious which policy responds, you are the one in the middle
None of these are unavoidable, and coordinating the two is exactly the work a broker is for. But they are the reason a single surplus lines contract is often worth paying a little more for. See how to read a DIC declarations page to check your own for these.
How we decide which to place
We do not have a house preference. The order we work is the same every time:
- Admitted carriers still writing your area first - if one will take the home, that is almost always the best outcome
- Then surplus lines, priced as a single policy, with the wildfire deductible and exclusions read carefully
- Then FAIR Plan plus a coordinated DIC wrap, when the first two paths are closed or come back worse
You see all three totals before you choose. See hard-to-insure homes in California for the full playbook, or FAIR Plan plus DIC cost and coverage for what the two-policy route runs.
Sources
Figures and definitions on this page come from the regulator or the body that publishes them. Each link was checked on the review date above.
- List of Approved Surplus Line Insurers (LASLI) California Department of Insurance
- Difference in Conditions (DIC) California FAIR Plan
- Wildfire resources and residential insurance California Department of Insurance
Frequently asked questions
Is surplus lines better than a FAIR Plan with a DIC wrap?
Often, but not always. Surplus lines is one policy with one deductible and one claims process, and it is frequently broader. The trade-off is that it is not backed by the California Insurance Guarantee Association, and the carrier still has to be willing to write your home. The FAIR Plan is available to essentially everyone who qualifies.
Which one is cheaper?
It depends on the home, and the comparison people get wrong is comparing a surplus lines quote against the FAIR Plan premium alone. The fair comparison is surplus lines against the FAIR Plan premium plus the DIC premium plus any fees. Once you add the second premium, the two are often closer than expected.
Can I switch from FAIR Plan plus DIC to surplus lines later?
Yes, and it is worth re-shopping at every renewal. The California market is moving quickly and carriers re-enter areas they had left. A home that could only get FAIR Plan plus DIC last year may have admitted or surplus lines options this year.
Does the DIC policy have the CIGA problem too?
It depends on which carrier writes it. Some DIC wraps are written by admitted carriers and some by non-admitted ones, so it is a question worth asking directly about your specific quote rather than assuming either way.
Get your free quote
Tell us what you need and a licensed California broker will reach out with real options. Simple situation or complicated one, we shop it the same way.
California only, for now. We are licensed in California and that is where we write.
What you can do right now
- RentersQuote and buy online in minutes
- CyberComing soon
- AutoComing soon
- HomeComing soon
- PetComing soon
Something a form cannot handle - wildfire, FAIR Plan, SR-22, a claims history? Send us the details and a licensed broker will work it by hand.